The Baha\u2019is claim that Sheikh Morteza Ansari who was one of the greatest scholars of Shia and contemporary to Hussein Ali Nouri hasn\u2019t excommunicated him and hasn\u2019t criticized him at all.<\/p>\n
Answer: Narrated by Sheikh Ansari\u2019s pupil, Hajji Mirza Nasrullah Torab Dezfouli was even careful about Seyyed Kazem Rashti and didn\u2019t consider him as merited for faking possession of Imam\u2019s property.[1]<\/a> Hajji Mullah Ali Kani, the influential jurisconsult of Tehran living in Naseruddin Shah\u2019s era, was considered as one the firm opponents of Bab.<\/p>\n Hajji Mullah Hadi Sabzevari, famous Shia sage living in Naseruddin Shah\u2019s era, has considered Sheikh Ahmad Ehsaee\u2019s knowledge rank as inferior. When a person like Ehsaee is considered as inferior according to sage Sabzevari, Bab and Azal\u2019s conditions are clear and obvious![2]<\/a><\/p>\n Seyyed Ahmad Mousavi Madadi writes in book Bab\u2019s sedition that it was considered as the greatest social event. Late Sheikh Ansari didn\u2019t show any reaction. I myself have heard orally that he considered the movement as a directed political game by the court.[3]<\/a><\/p>\n The scholar who issued the verdict for the excommunication of Mirza Hussein Ali Nouri and the necessity for killing Babism and Baha\u2019ism followers were mostly of Sheikh Ansari\u2019s school.<\/p>\n Mirza Hussein Ali Nouri was pretending to be Muslim. So, since his residence in Baqdad to earlier period living in Acre he didn\u2019t consider himself as the one who God will manifest and was trying not to perk himself to be out of Islam circle and he was performing Islamic rituals in Acre.[4]<\/a><\/p>\n Shoqi said: many Muslims participated at his funeral reciting the holy Quran verses and Haifa Mufti gave a speech there.[5]<\/a><\/p>\n In the last days of Abdul Baha\u2019s lifetime, he pretended to be Muslim like his father, Hussein Ali Baha. He was going to mosque to pray in group and he didn\u2019t quit it till two days before his death.[6]<\/a><\/p>\n In his books, Sheikh Ansari has declared clearly that the rejecter of prayer, and the fifth and the physical resurrection as pagan and unclean. For this reason, it is impossible for Hussein Ali Nouri to pose his claims in the presence of Sheikh Ansari. Surely, he has pretended to be oppressed and absolved himself for the fear of Sheikh\u2019s verdict for his excommunication.<\/p>\n Sometimes, the scholars weren\u2019t participating at such games due to political reasons. Because, they assume as a kind of game by the arrogance. For instance, Imam Khomeini (P.H.) had advised his son Hajji Ahmad Agha (P.H.). \u201cDon\u2019t enter into differences between the scholars and the pulpit concerning books or other things.[7]<\/a>\u201d<\/p>\n Imam Khomeini (P.H.) considered this issue as a kind of game by the arrogance like Fishing in troubled water.<\/p>\n It seems Sheikh Ansari\u2019s view towards Bab\u2019ism and Baha\u2019ism resembles Imam\u2019s one concerning this issue that both of them are from arrogance to plunder the Islamic countries particularly if Hussein Ali Nouri told lies and absolved himself.<\/p>\n <\/p>\n [\u06f1]<\/a> Ansari, 1369, Vol. 3, pp. 109-110.<\/p>\n [\u06f2]<\/a> Rowhani, 1386.<\/p>\n [\u06f3]<\/a> Mousavi Madadi, 1371, p. 15.<\/p>\n [\u06f4]<\/a> Kasrawi, 1323, pp. 60-62.<\/p>\n [\u06f5]<\/a> Great Islamic Encychlopedia, 1381, Vol. 11, p. 118.<\/p>\n